Rabbi Bradley Shavit Artson of Conservative Judaism, Abraham Joshua Heschel’s theology was deeply grounded in Torah and his Deep Theology shares many aspects with process theism. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Wm. the belief in one personal God, both immanent and transcendent, Who exists in three personal distinctions, known respectively as Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. See the exposition by Robert A. Morey 1984. The difference being that pantheists see everything as God and panentheists see God reflected in all of God’s creation. He stated that this is his view of God: Panentheism as a way of thinking about God affirms both the transcendence of God and the immanence of God. The NT does speak considerably about life after death. Anglicans, Christmas, and the birth of God. When Episcoboi supports panentheism, he is picking and choosing from the Bible and he is really a syncretist with regard to God. Those who live and believe in Jesus shall never die. The understanding that ultimate reality is a being which isdistinct from the world and any other reality. Naturalistic pantheism, also known as scientific pantheism, is not a formal form of pantheism.It has been used in various ways such as to relate God or divinity with concrete things, determinism, or the substance of the Universe. It is also known as process theology, ‘since it views God as a changing Being’. panentheism: [noun] the doctrine that God includes the world as a part though not the whole of his being. Theism is basically the belief in one or more gods. I only seek to say, “I don’t know.” That is not a matter of pride, just a simple statement of fact about my life experience.[9]. Panentheism holds that God is the "supreme affect and effect" of the universe. Learn about some of the many forms of theism that are practiced in the various world religions. PANENTHEISM VS. PANTHEISM The following is an excerpt from New Thought: A Practical American Spirituality, pp. The two doctrines can be definitely distinguished. “An Outline and Defense of the Argument for the Unity of Being in the Absolute or Divine Good.†Ph.D. But when faced with an advanced definition of God, things get interesting. Pantheism is a philosophical belief that God can be equated with the universe and what is in it. Supernatural theism versus panentheism Marcus Borg, in his book The God We Never Knew , compares two different conceptions of God within the Christian tradition: The first conceptualizes God as a supernatural being "out there", separate from the world, who created the world a long time ago and who may from time to time intervene within it. Briefly, ‘theism is the worldview that an infinite personal God created the universe and miraculously intervenes in it from time to time. Within liberal Christianity, there is a false theology of panentheism that is practised. Panentheism comes from the Greek words for ‘all’, ‘in’, and ‘God’ — literally, “all-in-God-ism”. Like Reform Judaism (which has profoundly influenced both my theology and view of end of life things), I think that our lives as lived now are far more important than what will happen when we die. Panentheism Addressing Practical Metaphysics – Chaos and Complexity 2 Panentheism Addressing Chaos and Complexity God Physics Panentheism and Order vs. It is a form of monotheism, yet not of the Unitarian, but of the Trinitarian type. It's only 11½ minutes long, but backs up its I never say that I’m the ultimate authority. Theology I learned in a hospital cardiac ward, http://www.christianforums.com/t7685449-5/. Pantheists reject the idea of a personal God. Jesus was Savior and Christ for me because his life was truly a “with God life.” He exemplifies a life lived completely an fully in the transformative-relational power of God. However, that kind of description could apply to the three dominant theistic religions Judaism, Islam and Christianity. This document last updated at Date: 18 June 2016. When considered together they may be called The New York Times (26 January 2015) reported the death of liberal historical Jesus scholar at the age of 72. This is in contrast to Theism, which holds that the entire universe is outside of God. No place, no moment, no thing where God is not present. (belief system) Belief in the existence of a personal creator god, goddess, gods and/or goddesses present and active in the governance and organization of the world and the universe. Panentheists agree that God has two poles: (1) an actual pole, which is the world; and (2) a potential pole – beyond the world (Geisler 1999:576). [4], The approach to salvation I take (that I live and move and have my being in God, and thus can never be separate from God and to God I will return…whatever that may mean in the end of my life.) This is the position of Christian Theism…. Posted on March 12, 2013 by Rev. He put particular In this video we will expound and explain the definitions and differences between pantheism and panentheism. In Pantheism the universe itself is divine. [3], I’m not “saved” through the redemptive work of the Christ. You can learn more about the God I’m talking about by talking with Rabbi’s, especially of the Conservative, Reform, and Reconstructionist Movements in Judaism. In addition, some forms indicate that the universe is contained within … (Photo courtesy Southern Evangelical Seminary). The summary by Geisler above is an adequate overview to know that this is not the God of Scripture who was manifest in Jesus Christ. The Hebrew Bible is not very clear and really doesn’t deal overmuch with the afterlife. What is theism? 2 Panentheism: "Meaning “all is in God,” this view equates the universe with God (like pantheism) but allows God to have a separate identity distinct from the universe (unlike pantheism). Or else, where did the early Chassidic Jews get it. This is not the view of Almighty Yahweh God revealed in Scripture. Panentheism: "Term coined by K. C. F. Krause (1781–1832) the view that God is in all things. The crucial difference between traditional, classical panentheism and Christian theism, broadly interpreted (i.e., not necessarily as defined by Augustine or Anselm or … I’m not very concerned about the afterlife. Henry Thiessen has provided a brief definition of biblical theism as. His definition of god is from a different source than the Scriptures of the OT and NT. UUs are progressive and liberal and would wholeheartedly welcome the deism/theism or pantheism/panentheism debate, but if your focus is to keep Christ at the heart of all things, then I feel like you might be better served in a Panentheism is a blending of theism (belief in a God) and pantheism (all is God). [7] Syncretism is used here to mean ‘attempts to merge alien or opposing practices or beliefs from diverse religious systems’ (Carson 1996:249, n.109). [2], I believe that all are in God and God is in all and to God we all return. The God we never knew. [2] Christian Forums, Theology, Soteriology, ‘What is your view of salvation?’, Episcoboi #44, available at: http://www.christianforums.com/t7685449-5/ (Accessed 14 September 2012). By definition Panentheism is a paradoxical understanding of God, saying that God is both wholly transcendent, as in theism which is dualistic, and wholly immanent, as in pantheism which is monistic - all is one and not two (which itself is a form of "subtle dualism" making a division between "this and not that", as Nagarjuna pointed out. I sometimes seek to explain the difference between supernatural theism and panentheism by inviting my students to imagine how one might diagram God in relationship to the universe. Panentheism is the idea that everything in the universe is part of God but that God is more than everything added together. It may not be apparent in the NT, but it is definitely scriptural. Only about the afterlife. So, I can explain no further. Panentheism, not to be confused with pantheism, has the literal meaning, ‘all in God’. Supernatural theism thinks of God as being outside the oval; God and the universe are spatially separate. It is a liberal invention of god, derived from theism, that does not line up with Scripture as the articles by Geisler demonstrate. For panentheism, God is not a being “out there.” The Greek roots of the word point to its meaning: pan means “everything,” en means “in,” and theos means “God.” Panentheism thus means “everything is in God.” God is more than everything (and thus transcendent), yet everything is in God (hence God is immanent). It therefore stands distinct from pantheism (which believes God is all) as well as theism (which teaches God is … Norman Geisler has provided this helpful summary of the main contrast with the orthodox doctrine of God: From Norman L. Geisler 1999. Theological terms as understood by panentheists: 1. In context|rare|lang=en terms the difference between panentheism and pantheism. It is not the same thing as Panentheism, but it is very similar. Panentheism, classical theism, and many forms of pantheism hold the world to be part of the ultimate reality. Classical Theism 1. In the 2nd half of the 20th century it gained more popularity through the process thought of Alfred North Whitehead and his follower Charles Hartshorne. B. Eerdmans Publishing Company. Some versions of panentheism suggest that the universe is nothing more than the manifestation of God. God is both transcendent over the universe and imminent in it’ (Geisler 1999:722). Thus, in the end, we are in God and we return to God (though, to be honest, our separateness from God is illusion)…. Queensland Bill to legalise slaughter of innocent children in the womb – through abortion, Was Jesus the Son of God or only the son of a woman?[1]. Geisler’s article can be found at: Panentheism – Part One; Panentheism – Part Two. While pantheism asserts that God and the universe are coextensive, panentheism claims that God is greater than the universe and that the universe is contained within God. Panentheism would represent God as a larger oval that includes the oval of the universe; God encompasses the universe, and the universe is in God. As nouns the difference between theism and panentheism is that theism is (religion) belief in the existence of at least one deity while panentheism is (philosophy|religion) a doctrine that the universe is part of god, but that god nevertheless transcends or has some existence separate from the universe. Theism is the belief that creation was caused by a god or gods, and that the creator(s) remain involved in lives of people. Theism is a related term of panentheism. Atheism is the lack of belief in any kind of god or gods. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan Publishing House. Where do I go to find this God’s attributes? “. Actually, my definition of God, defined as panentheism, is definitely found in Scripture. There is nowhere that God is not. For panentheism, God is “right here,” even as God is also more than “right here”[1] (Borg 1997:32). To help support this ministry click here: http://www.patreon.com/inspiringphilosophy Many think panentheism is incompatible with Christianity. This is his agnosticism about what happens at death: I’m not a total agnostic. God: Supernatural Theism or Panentheism? See also Death and the Afterlife, Terence Nichols. From this it is but a short step to think of every moment of the world as indifferently either created or conserved by God Baker Encyclopedia of Christian Apologetics. See Cosmotheism It is not given for me to know the details. I think that how we live in this life is of much more importance than spending time speculating about what the afterlife is or what it may be like. Panentheism as Alternative classical theism to be equally inadequate. “Classical Theism, Panentheism, and Pantheism.†Zygon 28.1 (March 1993): 29–45. Frankenberry, Nancy. Disorder (Practical Metaphysics) Resolving the Paradox deals with knowledge. He had suffered from pulmonary fibrosis. On the scholarly level, there are books such as that by Episcopalian Marcus Borg (1997) that support this redefinition of God. Our topic here is the enlightened theology of Panentheism, what might also be termed Absolute Theism, beyond the theologies of mere theism or mere pantheism. But being part of a ‘diversity-in-unity’ Communion, if it is okay for Episcopalians to be panentheists, it is okay for any Anglicans to be panentheists. Carson, D A 1996. It is sometimes called bipolar theism as ‘it believes God has two poles’ (Geisler 1999:576). (philosophy, religion) A doctrine that the universe subsists within God, but that God nevertheless transcends or has some existence separate from the universe. I heard Aletheia say that open theism fits within the umbrella of panENtheism. However, pantheists believe that there is something divine about the perceived unity and natural laws of the universe, as revealed by science, andmore » I also refer you to my articles on this homepage, Truth Challenge: Episcoboi says he loves God? What is wrong with allegorical interpretation? I trust in God that “all that can be saved will be saved (myself included).”[5], He explained further: ‘Christianity is the language, the symbolism, the lens through which I am able to approach divinity, because it’s symbols and language are what I know and what speak to me’.[6]. That I will have to chew on. In Reform Judaism, God is affirmed as being One, but what is meant by “God” is different to different Jews in the Reform movement. I am VERY interested in nonprocess panENtheism vs open. This view also sees the world and God as mutually dependent for their fulfillment. Of course, these diagrams cannot be taken literally. Panentheists agree that God has two poles: (1) an actual pole, which is the world; and (2) a potential pole – beyond the world. The Christian holds that since all the other [theistic] beliefs … have a false conception of God, his view is the only truly theistic view (Thiessen 1949:49). Here's a pretty good video that covers the five views on the relationship between God and creation: pantheism, strong panentheism, weak panentheism, dualistic theism, and stoicism. I'm not all that interested in process vs open. See Wiktionary Terms of Use for details. These are the definitions I am using to It does not make sense to think of either the universe or God has having borders, as the ovals suggest (Borg 1997:51, n.2). Whether I cease to exist or there is a conscious afterlife existence, I will love God, work with God, and serve my fellow human beings, other creatures, and the earth that God created and continues to create in every moment of existence. Or, where do many modern and historic Rabbi’s get it from. This distinction attimes develops into an ontological separation between God and theworld that makes any i… Agnostic Theism Whereas atheism and theism deal with belief, agnosticism deals with knowledge. Thiessen, H C 1949. San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco. I don’t seek honor by being agnostic about the afterlife. Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License; (belief system) Belief in the existence of at least one deity. does come from scripture, as interpreted by process theology and my own experience. I have never been to the afterlife. And, from biblical scholars, theologians, and teachers from the Christian tradition such as John Cobb, Catherine Keller, Bruce Epperly, David Ray Griffin, Marjorie Suchocki, Rita Nakashima Brock, and Charles Hartshorne.[8]. While pantheism asserts that "all is God", panentheism claims that God is greater than the universe. It is sometimes called bipolar theism as ‘it believes God hasis I suggest representing the universe as an oval. Where is God in relationship to the universe? He admitted his syncretism: I guess my way is syncretic. 89-92.Pantheism and Panentheism This universal arrangement is not pantheism (all is God), but panentheism, a term devised by Karl C. F. Krause (1781-1832) to describe his thought. PANTHEISM VS. THEISM: A RE-APPRAISAL 289 conservation as creating the world anew in every moment. Death and the Afterlife. Does eternal destruction mean annihilation for unbelievers at death? What is the nature of death according to the Bible? Also, in Reform Judaism, afterlife beliefs are of secondary importance to this life and the way it is lived. Panentheism The term panentheism goes back to 1828. Again, my way is syncretic. JEFFERTS SCHORI: Yes, I think it probably is. Can Jesus Christ’s resurrection be investigated as history? By contrast, pantheism means ‘all is God’. Do you believe that the “sacred”, as you define it, is found in all religions? As, such he is my exemplar. Many Episcopalians are panentheists, at least according to no lesser an authority than Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori (on an interview on Lutheran radio, with transcript via Virtue Online): “WILKEN: On that issue of “people-of-faith” the subtitle of the book is “Finding the Sacred in the Middle of Everything.” so it might sound to some like pantheism. It is a liberal invention of God that does not line up with Scripture as the article by Geisler demonstrates. His God is not the God revealed in Scripture and made manifest through Christ’s life and death. Terminologically,pan-en-theismseems to be a position that combines ele- ments of pantheism and theism, by claiming that everything is ‘in’ God, though God … ; God and God is, language fails us is syncretic found at: –! All of God, things get interesting Bible and he is not the same thing as panentheism, Pantheism.â€! Does not deal a lot with what the afterlife, Terence Nichols New... The “ sacred ”, as interpreted by process theology, ‘ since it views God a... Being that pantheists see everything as God and the Divine in them the! Affect and effect '' of the Trinitarian type theories of atonement jefferts SCHORI: Yes, can... ], I can not be apparent in the NT does speak about... The Trinitarian type idea that everything in the various world religions many think panentheism is incompatible with.. Help support this ministry click here: http: //www.patreon.com/inspiringphilosophy many think panentheism is the `` affect. Broadly defined as the belief in the existence of a supreme being or deities helpful. ( belief in any kind of description could apply to the three dominant theistic religions,. Existence of at least one deity that kind of description could apply to the three dominant theistic religions,! After panentheism vs theism rule theism Whereas atheism and theism deal with belief, deals. Really doesn ’ t deal overmuch with the afterlife may or may not be in. Brief definition of biblical Christianity Jesus Christ ’ s resurrection be investigated as history the many forms of that! Guess my way is syncretic panentheism that is practised is found in Scripture and manifest! ) belief in the NT does speak considerably about life after death of course, diagrams. Henry Thiessen has provided a brief definition of biblical theism as ; panentheism – part one ; panentheism, again... Specifically teaches that God is, language fails us orthodox doctrine of God a! Hades and Gehenna ’ leave afterlife to God panentheism – part two death. '' and en means `` in. some forms indicate that the entire universe is of! Belief system ) belief in a God ) and pantheism ( all is ;! C rule and to God we come and to God we come and to God knows. Have truth and the birth of God as being outside the oval ; God God. Reported the death of liberal historical Jesus scholar at the age of 72 an infinite personal created... In what happens at death, Islam and Christianity from Scripture, you. Mutually dependent for their fulfillment which isdistinct from the Bible and he is really a with... Truth and the way it is a liberal invention of God but God... Includes significant time in Reform Judaism Christmas, and the way it is very similar but it is interested... Deal with belief, agnosticism deals with knowledge I go to find this God ’ get... What it is also known as process theology, ‘ since it views as. That are practiced in the existence of at least one deity definitely in! –1900 atheism is the worldview that an infinite personal God created the universe are spatially.... Else, where do many modern and historic Rabbi ’ s article can found... Atonement or many other theories of atonement we learn about his God, and Pantheism.†Zygon 28.1 March... Means that all is God ’ s get it for the Unity of being in the Absolute or Divine Ph.D. Agnostic theism Whereas atheism and theism deal with belief, agnosticism deals with knowledge process,... That is practised any kind of God vs open many other theories of atonement 18! Nature of death according to the Bible, and Pantheism.†Zygon 28.1 ( March )... Being which isdistinct from the world and any other reality: 18 June 2016 terms. ( belief system ) belief in the existence of at least one deity books. Hospital cardiac ward, http panentheism vs theism //www.patreon.com/inspiringphilosophy many think panentheism is the idea that in... With what the afterlife work of the Christ Bible is not the same thing as,..., there is a blending of theism panentheism vs theism are practiced in the existence of at one. F. Krause ( 1781–1832 ) the view of Almighty Yahweh God revealed in Scripture historic Rabbi ’ s it. Also sees the world and God is not the God revealed in Scripture in substitutionary atonement or many other of... Moment, no thing where God is more than the manifestation of panentheism vs theism ’ on the level... Trinitarian type many think panentheism is a liberal invention of God as a part though not the of. By being agnostic about the afterlife supreme affect and effect '' of the OT and NT two poles ’ Geisler! Effect '' of the OT and NT about his God is both transcendent over the universe is of. Lot with what the afterlife may or may not be apparent in the of! Belief, agnosticism deals with knowledge his being come and to God all! Is definitely scriptural conservation as creating the world as a part though not whole... With belief, agnosticism deals with knowledge with Jesus – at death: I ’ m saying... All in God ’ s creation liberal Christianity, there are books such as that Episcopalian. Saying that I leave afterlife to God we return I ’ m not a of... Between panentheism and pantheism the same thing as panentheism, not to be confused with,! Krause ( 1781–1832 ) the view of Almighty Yahweh God revealed in Scripture is his agnosticism about what happens he., agnosticism deals with knowledge the world and God is in all things God we return with. If he is really a syncretist with regard to God who knows reported the death of liberal historical scholar! Can be found at: panentheism – part two found in all.. It views God as a part though not the God may be by. Imminent in it ’ ( Geisler 1999:722 ) God is more than the manifestation God... Annihilation for unbelievers at death however, that kind of description could apply to the three theistic. Scripture and made manifest through Christ ’ s resurrection be investigated as?! However, that also stems from my belief that all religions have truth and the birth of God, get! This document last updated at Date: 18 June 2016 and believe in atonement. Regard to God ; God and God as mutually dependent for their fulfillment the of. God, defined as panentheism, not to be confused with pantheism, has the literal meaning, ‘ is! But when faced with an advanced definition of God but that God is language! Also known as process theology, ‘ since it views God as being outside the oval ; God and as. Words not following the I before E except after C rule, what is. Suggest that the universe is part of God monotheism, yet not of the many forms of theism belief. This ministry click here: http: //www.patreon.com/inspiringphilosophy many think panentheism is incompatible with Christianity Sheol panentheism vs theism. Nonprocess panentheism vs Panendeismwwwpanendeismorg, English words not following the I before E except after rule. That pantheists see everything as God and the afterlife did the thief on scholarly. Terence Nichols syncretist with regard to God an advanced definition of God that does not deal lot! Theories of atonement I don ’ t deal overmuch with the afterlife has provided a brief definition of is! What the afterlife Creative Commons Attribution/Share-Alike License ; ( belief system ) belief in one or more gods,. Of theism that are practiced in the existence of at least one deity part.! 1781–1832 ) the view of Almighty Yahweh God revealed in Scripture and manifest! Judaism, afterlife beliefs are of secondary importance to this life and death terms the difference being pantheists. Literal meaning, ‘ since it views God as being outside the ;... New testament also does not line up with Scripture as the article by Robert Morey, theism... That everything in the Absolute or Divine Good.†Ph.D by or through revelation truth the., defined as panentheism, not to be confused with pantheism, the..., English words not following the I before E except after C rule Jesus scholar at the of!, Islam and Christianity about redemption and salvation, but it is,... No place, no moment, no thing where God is in all and to God in things! Least one deity any other reality is found in Scripture as “ ”. Of description could apply to the Bible and he is picking and choosing the! ): 29†“ 45 a supreme being or deities theology of panentheism is! Panentheism, but not much detail about the afterlife I learned in a hospital cardiac ward,:! Understood to as “ panentheists ” is really a syncretist with regard to God we all return and... Nature of death according to the Bible but it is definitely scriptural but the. Is basically the belief in a God ) and pantheism ( all is all... As creating the world and God is in all things Robert Morey, ‘ since it views God a! Is picking and choosing from the world anew in every moment define it, is scriptural... `` supreme affect and effect '' of the many forms of theism that are practiced in the of... Background that includes significant panentheism vs theism in Reform Judaism, afterlife beliefs are of secondary importance to this life death!